Top 5 Murder Defense Lawyers in Bowling Green, KY (2026)

Attorney Dossier · Bowling Green · November 2026

Five Bowling Green law offices that take homicide and violent felony cases, checked against their own sites and Google.

A murder charge in Warren County is a capital case heard in Circuit Court, and Kentucky sets no time limit on bringing it. The lawyer’s trial record matters more here than in almost any other case, so the background check comes before the retainer.

0 of 5
offices here publish a fee for a homicide case
20 to 50 years
the shortest prison term range for a capital murder conviction
$0
appointed counsel if you cannot afford a lawyer

John Caudill Attorney at Law is listed first on this page. The order of the other four is not a ranking. Ratings and review themes come from Google; practice claims are each firm’s own statements.

01

The scorecard: 5 checks, 5 firms

✓ meets the check   ◐ partly or self-reported   ✗ does not, or not published

John Caudill Attorney at LawHomicide cases that may involve federal charges or federal agents
Bowling Green office
✓College St
Homicide listed on site
✓Murder page
Practice since (firm-stated)
◐Practice since 1989 (AUSA)
Fee terms published
◐Free consult only
Google rating checked
✓4.9 from 60
Kevin R. Croslin, Attorney at LawLower-level charges and traffic cases handled by a solo lawyer
Bowling Green office
✓E 13th Ave
Homicide listed on site
✗Not listed
Practice since (firm-stated)
✓Since 2009
Fee terms published
◐Free consult only
Google rating checked
✓4.1 from 38
Cole Loney, PLLCDefendants who want a lawyer with state and federal trial admission back to 1994
Bowling Green office
✓Ashley Cir
Homicide listed on site
◐General criminal page
Practice since (firm-stated)
✓Since 1994
Fee terms published
◐Free consult only
Google rating checked
✓4.9 from 34
The Simpson FirmFamilies who want a multi-lawyer team that has handled murder cases since 1988
Bowling Green office
✓State St
Homicide listed on site
✓Murder cases stated
Practice since (firm-stated)
◐Since 1988 (firm)
Fee terms published
◐Free consult only
Google rating checked
✓4.0 from 29
Matthew J BakerClients who want a long-established downtown office and prompt replies
Bowling Green office
✓E Main Ave
Homicide listed on site
✗Not confirmed
Practice since (firm-stated)
✗Not confirmed
Fee terms published
✗Not published
Google rating checked
✓3.8 from 55
02

Before you hire: what the numbers mean for a Bowling Green homicide case

1
0 of 5: offices here publish a fee for a homicide case
None of the five posts a fee. Four state a free first consultation: John Caudill, Kevin Croslin, Cole Loney and The Simpson Firm; Matthew J Baker’s site could not be read. Ask for the fee in writing, including investigators, outside witnesses and what happens if the case goes to trial.
SOURCE · Firm websites, read November 2026
2
20 to 50 years: the shortest prison term range for a capital murder conviction
Under KRS 532.030, a capital offense such as murder carries death, life without parole, life without parole for 25 years, life, or a term of 20 to 50 years. Kentucky also sets no time limit on charging a felony (KRS 500.050), so an old case can still be brought.
SOURCE · KRS 532.030 and 500.050
3
$0: appointed counsel if you cannot afford a lawyer
A defendant who cannot afford a lawyer can ask the court to appoint a public defender from the Kentucky Department of Public Advocacy. Raise it at the first appearance in Warren District Court, before the case moves to Circuit Court.
SOURCE · Kentucky Department of Public Advocacy
03

The 5 firm dossiers

01

John Caudill Attorney at Law

Homicide cases that may involve federal charges or federal agents
Why it made the list

John Caudill Attorney at Law works from College Street, a block from the Warren County Justice Center where Circuit Court hears murder cases. Its murder defense page explains how Kentucky separates murder from first and second degree manslaughter by intent, and notes that murder is a capital offense. The firm states John Caudill was an Assistant U.S. Attorney in Louisville from 1989 to 2005, tried more than 50 cases to a jury verdict, and has prosecuted and defended homicide and violent crime cases in state and federal court. It states the first consultation is free.

Proof file
  • Lead attorneyJohn Caudill · Firm website
  • BackgroundStates he was an Assistant U.S. Attorney from 1989 to 2005 with more than 50 jury trials · Firm’s own statement
  • Office911 College St, Suite 203, Bowling Green, KY 42101 · Firm site and Google
  • Phone270-925-0447 · Firm site and Google (agree)
  • Homicide workMurder, manslaughter, homicide and kidnapping defense pages · Firm website
  • Fee termsFree consultation; fees not published · Firm website
  • Google rating4.9 from 60 reviews · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QHow many homicide cases have you defended, and how many went to trial in Warren Circuit Court?
QHow would you handle a bond hearing for a capital murder charge?
QDo you bring in an investigator or second chair for a homicide trial, and how is that billed?
From the reviews we read
+ Charges reduced or dropped+ Calm and plain-spoken+ Federal case outcomes~ No homicide reviews seen

Reviewers describe felony charges reduced or dropped, a federal drug defendant who was the only one of 33 to get probation, and a calm, plain-spoken approach with families. The reviews we read do not describe a homicide trial specifically, so ask about recent murder or manslaughter cases.

Fit and watch-outThe only lawyer here with a published federal prosecutor background, a block from the courthouse. The trade-off: it is a solo practice, so ask how a long homicide trial is staffed alongside other cases.
02

Kevin R. Croslin, Attorney at Law

Lower-level charges and traffic cases handled by a solo lawyer
Why it made the list

Kevin R. Croslin, Attorney at Law is a sole practitioner on East 13th Avenue, south of downtown. His criminal defense pages describe charges from drug possession and DUI to bail jumping and burglary, and the site states he began practicing in Kentucky in 2009. The same site says he has focused on estate planning and probate in recent years, and it does not list homicide or violent felony defense. As a sole practitioner, the site says clients always talk to him directly, and it offers a free initial consultation with weekday hours.

Proof file
  • Lead attorneyKevin R. Croslin, practicing in Kentucky since 2009 · Firm’s own statement
  • Office1027 E 13th Ave, Bowling Green, KY 42104 · Firm site and Google
  • Phone270-842-1599 · Firm site and Google (agree)
  • Practice focusCriminal defense, traffic and probate; site says recent focus is estate planning and probate · Firm website
  • Fee termsFree initial consultation; fees not published · Firm website
  • HoursWeekdays 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. · Firm site and Google
  • Google rating4.1 from 38 reviews · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QHave you defended a murder or manslaughter charge, and when was the last one?
QHow much of your current practice is criminal defense versus probate?
QWho covers court dates if you are in another hearing?
From the reviews we read
+ Traffic case results+ Helpful assistant~ Slow replies in two reviews~ No homicide work listed

Reviewers praise results in traffic and speeding cases and name his assistant Jennifer as helpful and quick to respond. Two recent reviewers describe little effort and slow replies in criminal matters, including one serious case. None of the reviews we read describe a homicide case.

Fit and watch-outDirect access to one lawyer and a published free consultation. The trade-off: the site says his recent focus is probate and estate planning and lists no homicide work, so a murder charge needs a direct conversation about experience.
03

Cole Loney, PLLC

Defendants who want a lawyer with state and federal trial admission back to 1994
Why it made the list

Cole Loney, PLLC is a two-partner firm on Ashley Circle, off Scottsville Road. Its criminal law page says the firm defends criminal charges across Kentucky, takes cases to trial on request and answers calls 24 hours a day with a free first consultation. John David Cole Jr., a Bowling Green native, was admitted to the Kentucky and federal bars in 1994, is admitted before the U.S. Supreme Court and the Sixth Circuit, and the firm states he has more than 20 years of criminal defense in state and federal courts. Partner Joseph Loney focuses on business, real estate and estate planning.

Proof file
  • Criminal partnerJohn David Cole Jr., admitted to Kentucky and federal bars in 1994 · Firm attorney page
  • Court admissionsU.S. Supreme Court, Sixth Circuit, Eastern and Western Districts of Kentucky · Firm’s own statement
  • Office1705 Ashley Cir, Bowling Green, KY 42104 · Firm site and Google
  • Phone270-843-9212 · Firm site and Google (agree)
  • Fee termsFree initial consultation; fees not published · Firm criminal law page
  • AvailabilityStates it is available 24 hours a day · Firm’s own statement
  • Google rating4.9 from 34 reviews · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QHow many homicide cases has David Cole tried in Warren Circuit Court?
QWho on your team would handle discovery and witness interviews in a murder case?
QDoes your 24-hour line reach an attorney, and what happens at a first bond hearing?
From the reviews we read
+ Clear explanations+ Friendly staff~ Mostly transactional reviews

Most reviews we read describe Joe Loney’s business, real estate and estate work, and praise clear explanations and a friendly staff. One long-time client says both partners have handled varied matters for years. Few reviews describe criminal cases, so the criminal record rests mainly on the firm’s own statements.

Fit and watch-outA criminal partner with long federal and appellate admissions and a free, around-the-clock first call. The trade-off: the firm splits its work with transactional practice, and few reviews describe criminal cases.
04

The Simpson Firm

Families who want a multi-lawyer team that has handled murder cases since 1988
Why it made the list

The Simpson Firm is on State Street downtown, a short walk from the Justice Center. Its criminal defense description says the firm has practiced since 1988 and has handled criminal matters from speeding tickets to complex murder cases, alongside personal injury, medical negligence and family law. B. Alan Simpson leads a team that includes J. Blake Beliles, Olivia Hester and Ashlea Shepherd Porter, and the site lists emergency numbers for three of the lawyers. The firm states it offers a free consultation, and its Google listing appears under B. Alan Simpson’s name.

Proof file
  • Lead attorneyB. Alan Simpson; team includes J. Blake Beliles, Olivia Hester, Ashlea Shepherd Porter · Firm website
  • Track recordStates practice since 1988, with cases from speeding tickets to complex murder · Firm’s own statement
  • Office908 State St, Bowling Green, KY 42101 · Firm site and Google
  • Phone270-782-3929 · Firm site and Google (agree)
  • Fee termsFree consultation; fees not published · Firm website
  • HoursWeekdays 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.; attorney emergency numbers listed · Google and firm site
  • Google rating4.0 from 29 reviews (listed as B. Alan Simpson) · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QWhich attorney here has tried a murder case to verdict, and when?
QHow do the emergency numbers on your site work after an arrest at night?
QWhat does your fee cover for a homicide case through trial and sentencing?
From the reviews we read
+ Close contact in a federal case+ Responsive divorce counsel~ Continuances and plea complaints

One family describes a federal case where Alan Simpson and the staff stayed in close touch, and divorce clients praise Ashlea Shepherd Porter. Two reviewers describe criminal cases they felt went badly, one citing a year of continuances in a DUI case and one a large fee that ended in a plea.

Fit and watch-outOne of two offices here that publish murder work, with several lawyers and after-hours numbers. The trade-off: the practice also covers injury and divorce, and two critical reviews describe criminal cases that dragged on.
05

Matthew J Baker

Clients who want a long-established downtown office and prompt replies
Why it made the list

Matthew J Baker practices from an office on East Main Avenue, a few blocks from Fountain Square and the courthouses. His criminal defense page could not be read during our check because the site blocked automated access, so the details here come from his Google listing. That listing shows weekday hours from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. and 55 reviews. Reviewers describe him as prompt, honest about which facts matter and easy to understand, and several have used his office for years. Ask him directly about homicide trial experience.

Proof file
  • Lead attorneyMatthew J. Baker · Google listing
  • Office561 E Main Ave, Bowling Green, KY 42101 · Google listing
  • Phone270-746-2385 · Google listing
  • HoursWeekdays 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. · Google listing
  • Practice detailsNot confirmed; the firm website blocked our check · Firm website, attempted November 2026
  • Google rating3.8 from 55 reviews · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QHow many homicide cases have you handled, and in which courts?
QWhat share of your current practice is criminal defense?
QIs the first consultation free, and how is a murder case fee structured?
From the reviews we read
+ Prompt and responsive+ Plain explanations~ Lowest rating here

Reviewers describe prompt replies, plain explanations and long-term relationships with the office. The review base is the largest outside the client, but the rating is the lowest here, and we could not read the text of criminal-specific reviews to judge homicide work.

Fit and watch-outA long-running downtown office with a sizable review base. The trade-off: we could not verify his criminal or homicide practice from his own site, and his 3.8 rating is the lowest in this group.
04

Six things to settle before you sign for a homicide defense

Who tries the case. Name the lead trial lawyer and any second chair, and confirm they have tried a homicide case to verdict.
The fee in writing. Get the amount and what it covers through trial, sentencing and any appeal on paper before work starts.
Investigators and witnesses. Ask whether a defense investigator or forensic or medical witness is planned and who pays for each.
Bond strategy. Ask how the firm will approach bond for a capital charge and how quickly it can get a hearing.
Federal exposure. If guns, drugs or crossing state lines are involved, ask whether federal charges are possible.
Licence check. Confirm the lawyer is in good standing with the Kentucky Bar Association before you sign.
05

Frequently asked questions

Who are the top murder defense lawyers in Bowling Green, KY?+
This page compares John Caudill Attorney at Law, Kevin R. Croslin, Attorney at Law, Cole Loney, PLLC, The Simpson Firm and Matthew J Baker. All have Bowling Green offices. The order is not a ranking.
What sentence can a murder conviction carry in Kentucky?+
Murder is a capital offense. Under KRS 532.030 the sentence can be death, life without parole, life without parole for 25 years, life, or a term of 20 to 50 years.
Is there a time limit to charge murder in Kentucky?+
No. KRS 500.050 sets no time limit for felonies, including murder.
Where are murder cases heard in Bowling Green?+
Felony cases, including murder, are heard in Warren Circuit Court at the Warren County Justice Center, 1001 Center St.
Where is John Caudill Attorney at Law located?+
The office is at 911 College St, Suite 203, Bowling Green, KY 42101. The phone is 270-925-0447, and the firm states the first consultation is free.
Can I get a public defender for a murder charge in Kentucky?+
Yes, if you cannot afford a lawyer. The court appoints a public defender from the Kentucky Department of Public Advocacy.
06

Method and sources

How we checked these firms+

This is a shortlist of five Bowling Green law offices that take criminal cases, not a ranking. For each we read the page you supplied and the firm’s attorney pages where available, then checked the Google listing for address, phone, hours, rating and review text.

Where a firm publishes a background, a year or a result, we say it is the firm’s own statement. The Kentucky Bar Association’s public lookup could not be queried during this check, so licence status is not shown; verify it before hiring. Sentencing ranges come from the Kentucky Revised Statutes.

Sources+
  1. Firm websites: caudill.legal, croslinlaw.com, coleloney.com and balansimpsonlaw.com (read November 2026); mattbakerlaw.com could not be read
  2. Google Business Profiles for each office: address, phone, hours, rating, review count and review text (checked November 2026)
  3. KRS 532.030 (authorized sentences) and KRS 500.050 (time limitations)
  4. Kentucky Department of Public Advocacy

General information for law firm owners choosing a marketing vendor, not legal advice. Check the current statute text or ask ethics counsel before relying on it.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top