Top 5 Sex Crimes Defense Attorneys in Albany, NY (2026)

Firm Dossier · Albany, NY · November 2026

Five Capital Region firms that defend sex crime charges, checked against their own sites, Google profiles and New York’s registration rules.

A sex crime accusation in Albany County can bring prison time and a registration order that lasts 20 years or for life, so the first lawyer you call matters. These five firms all defend the accused; none of them publishes a fee, and their review records differ more than their websites suggest.

0 of 5
firms that publish a fee for sex crimes defense
20 years to life
how long New York sex offender registration lasts
$0
for a lawyer from the Albany County Public Defender if you qualify

O’Brien & Eggleston PLLC is listed first on this page. The order of the other four is not a ranking. Every fact below was checked against the source named beside it in November 2026.

01

The scorecard: 5 checks, 5 firms

✓ meets the check   ◐ partly or self-reported   ✗ does not, or not published

O’Brien & Eggleston PLLCPeople under investigation or charged in Albany who want a downtown firm a block from the County Courthouse
Albany County office

✓Downtown Albany

Bar record checked

◐Firm site

Sex crimes page

✓Own page

Fee terms published

◐Free consultation

Google rating checked

✓4.9 / 72

James E. Tyner, PLLCPeople facing a felony sex charge who want one trial lawyer handling the case personally
Albany County office

✓Latham

Bar record checked

◐Firm site

Sex crimes page

✓Several pages

Fee terms published

◐Free consultation

Google rating checked

✓4.4 / 39

Tully Rinckey PLLCStudents and service members facing a sex allegation that may also bring a Title IX or military proceeding
Albany County office

✓Latham

Bar record checked

◐Firm site

Sex crimes page

✓Own page

Fee terms published

✗Not stated

Google rating checked

✓4.8 / 534

O’Connell and AronowitzProfessionals whose license or career is at stake and who want former chief felony prosecutors on the defense
Albany County office

✓State St

Bar record checked

◐Firm site

Sex crimes page

◐Charge list only

Fee terms published

✗Not stated

Google rating checked

✓4.5 / 63

Martin P. Bonventre, Esq.People charged with a lower-level offense who want an affordable solo lawyer on State Street
Albany County office

✓State St

Bar record checked

◐Directory listing

Sex crimes page

◐Directory only

Fee terms published

◐Free consultation

Google rating checked

✓4.9 / 59

02

Before you hire: what the numbers mean in an Albany sex crime case

1
0 of 5: firms that publish a fee for sex crimes defense
Expect to ask. Three of the five advertise a free consultation on their sites or attorney profiles, but none posts a price, and sex crime cases often need investigators, forensic computer review or a defense psychologist at a registration hearing. Ask what the quoted fee covers and what happens to it if the case goes to trial.
SOURCE · Firm websites and attorney profiles, read November 2026
2
20 years to life: how long New York sex offender registration lasts
A judge sets a risk level after a hearing. Level 1 registrants are on the registry for 20 years; Level 2 and Level 3 register for life, and a Level 2 registrant without a special designation may petition for relief only after 30 years. That hearing is a separate fight from the criminal charge.
SOURCE · NY Division of Criminal Justice Services, sex offender risk levels; Correction Law 168-h and 168-o
3
$0: for a lawyer from the Albany County Public Defender if you qualify
Anyone charged with a crime who cannot afford a lawyer can ask the court to assign one at no cost. In Albany County that is usually the Public Defender’s Office on State Street, which also handles registration hearings for its clients. Ask at your arraignment if money is the barrier.
SOURCE · Albany County Public Defender, albanycounty.com

03

The 5 firm dossiers

01

O’Brien & Eggleston PLLC

People under investigation or charged in Albany who want a downtown firm a block from the County Courthouse
Why it made the list

O’Brien & Eggleston PLLC works from Sheridan Avenue, about a block from the Albany County Courthouse where felony sex cases are tried. Its Albany sex crimes defense lawyers page lists more than twenty offense types, from indecent exposure and statutory rape to child pornography and sex trafficking, and explains how a conviction can lead to public registration lasting from 20 years to life. Co-founders Kevin K. O’Brien and Adam C. Eggleston state they have more than 20 years of combined experience on both sides of New York’s criminal courtrooms and over 200 trials between them; those are the firm’s own figures. The firm also blogs on false accusations, delayed reporting and interrogation tactics.

Proof file
  • AttorneysKevin K. O’Brien, Adam C. Eggleston, Alex R. Shmulsky · Firm site; NY attorney registration not checked this run
  • Office12 Sheridan Ave, Suite 3, Albany, NY 12207 · Google, firm site
  • Phone518-391-2369 · Google, firm site
  • Charges listedSexual assault, statutory rape, child pornography, indecent exposure, sex trafficking and more · Firm sex crimes page
  • Experience claimOver 20 years combined; over 200 trials between the co-founders · Firm site, its own figures
  • Fee termsFree consultation; fees not published · Firm site
  • Google rating4.9 from 72 reviews · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QWho at the firm will handle my case, and how many sex crime trials has that attorney taken to verdict?
QIf I am only under investigation, will you speak to the detective for me before any charge is filed?
QDo you also handle the registration risk-level hearing if the case ends in a conviction or plea?
From the reviews we read
+ Straightforward about outcomes+ Reachable by cell phone+ Pushed for a better offer~ Reviews describe other charge types

The Google reviews we read describe attorneys who are straightforward about likely outcomes, reachable by cell phone and willing to push back for a better offer. Kevin O’Brien and Alex Shmulsky are named most often. The reviews we read describe DWI and other criminal matters rather than sex crime cases specifically.

Fit and watch-outA strong fit for someone charged in Albany who wants a firm steps from the courthouse with both prosecution and defense experience on its team. The trade-off: with five offices, ask who will actually stand beside you in court, and no fee is published.
02

James E. Tyner, PLLC

People facing a felony sex charge who want one trial lawyer handling the case personally
Why it made the list

James E. Tyner, PLLC is a Latham criminal defense practice whose Albany criminal defense lawyer site leads with sex crime defense: separate pages for rape, sexual assault, internet sex crimes, child pornography, forcible touching and sex crime entrapment. Its published results are mostly sex crime acquittals, including a not guilty verdict after a week-long first-degree rape trial and a verdict returned after 17 minutes of deliberation; those are the firm’s own results. James E. Tyner states he has more than 20 years of experience, handles each case personally and prepares every case as if it will go to trial. The office sits in Latham, about eight miles north of downtown.

Proof file
  • Lead attorneyJames E. Tyner · Firm site; NY attorney registration not checked this run
  • Office19 British American Blvd, Latham, NY 12110 · Google, firm site
  • Phone518-783-3800 on the site; Google lists 518-625-8651 · Firm site, Google
  • Sex crime pagesRape, sexual assault, internet sex crimes, child pornography, forcible touching, entrapment · Firm site
  • Results listedRape acquittal after a week-long trial; not guilty verdict after 17 minutes · Firm site, its own results
  • Fee termsFree consultation; credit cards accepted; fees not published · Firm site
  • Google rating4.4 from 39 reviews · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QHow many sex crime cases have you tried to verdict in Albany County Court, and how recently?
QWill you personally appear at every court date, or does anyone else cover?
QWhat does your fee include if the case goes to a full jury trial?
From the reviews we read
+ Responsive and professional+ Explained each step+ Charges dismissed~ Lowest average of the five

Reviewers describe James Tyner as responsive and professional, explaining each step from consultation to outcome, with dismissed charges and favorable deals. His 4.4 average is the lowest of the five firms, which suggests some lower ratings we did not see in written reviews.

Fit and watch-outThe most trial-focused sex crime practice of the five by its own published results, with direct access to the lawyer. The trade-off: a one-lawyer practice has less backup, and its Google average trails the others.
03

Tully Rinckey PLLC

Students and service members facing a sex allegation that may also bring a Title IX or military proceeding
Why it made the list

Tully Rinckey PLLC is a large multi-office firm whose Capital Region sex crime lawyers team is led by partner Derrick Hogan, who the firm says has defended a countless number of sex crime cases in the area. The page states that many team members started as prosecutors and covers forcible touching, criminal sexual act and rape under the Penal Law. The firm also runs Title IX and military law practices, which matters for a college student or service member whose accusation brings a campus or command proceeding alongside the criminal case. Its Google profile is the Latham office on Troy-Schenectady Road.

Proof file
  • Sex crimes team leadPartner Derrick Hogan · Firm sex crimes page; NY attorney registration not checked this run
  • Office1203 Troy-Schenectady Rd, Suite 101, Latham · Google
  • Phone888-529-4543 on the site; Google lists 518-218-7100 · Firm site, Google
  • Related practicesTitle IX, military law, federal crimes, sealing criminal records · Firm site
  • Counties servedAlbany and more than 20 other Capital Region and northern counties · Firm sex crimes page
  • Fee termsNot stated on the sex crimes page · Firm site
  • Google rating4.8 from 534 reviews, all practice areas · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QWill Derrick Hogan personally handle my case, and who covers his court dates?
QIf there is also a Title IX or military proceeding, will the same team handle both, and is that a separate fee?
QHow do you prevent my file being passed between attorneys during the case?
From the reviews we read
+ Named attorneys praised~ Passed between attorneys~ Retainer disputes~ Reviews mostly non-criminal

The firm’s 534 Google reviews cover every practice area, and the ones we read concern employment, divorce, real estate and landlord cases rather than criminal defense. Positive reviews praise named attorneys; several negative reviews describe being passed among multiple attorneys and disputes over retainers.

Fit and watch-outBest for an accusation that spans criminal court and a campus or military process. The trade-off: reviews describe handoffs between attorneys at a large firm, and its review base mostly reflects other practice areas.
04

O’Connell and Aronowitz

Professionals whose license or career is at stake and who want former chief felony prosecutors on the defense
Why it made the list

O’Connell and Aronowitz is a multi-practice firm at 54 State Street whose criminal defense team is led by Stephen Coffey and Michael McDermott, described by the firm as former chief felony prosecutors in the Albany and Rensselaer County District Attorney’s Offices. Its criminal page lists pornography charges among felonies, misdemeanors and college student defense, and a FindLaw listing names McDermott among sex crime lawyers serving Albany County. Because the firm also runs health law and professional discipline practices, it suits a doctor, nurse or teacher whose license board may act on the same accusation.

Proof file
  • Criminal team leadsStephen Coffey and Michael McDermott, described as former chief felony prosecutors · Firm criminal defense page, its own statement
  • Office54 State St, Albany, NY 12207; Latham office at 6 Airport Park Blvd · Firm site, Google
  • Phone518-462-5601 · Firm site, Google
  • Sex crime workPornography charges listed; McDermott listed among Albany County sex crime lawyers · Firm site; FindLaw listing
  • Related practicesProfessional discipline, health law, college student defense · Firm site
  • Fee termsNot stated · Firm site
  • Google rating4.5 from 63 reviews, Latham office profile · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QWill Stephen Coffey or Michael McDermott personally handle my case?
QIf my professional license is also at risk, will your discipline team coordinate with the criminal defense?
QHow many sex crime cases has the criminal team defended in Albany County in recent years?
From the reviews we read
+ Named attorneys praised+ Strong civil case results~ One brusque first call~ No sex crime reviews read

The 63 Google reviews sit on the firm’s Latham office profile. The ones we read praise Stephen Coffey and other attorneys on personal injury and civil cases; one describes a brusque first phone call with an attorney. We read no reviews that describe a sex crime defense.

Fit and watch-outA good fit for a licensed professional who needs criminal defense and license protection under one roof. The trade-off: sex crimes appear only as a line in a charge list, and fee terms are not published.
05

Martin P. Bonventre, Esq.

People charged with a lower-level offense who want an affordable solo lawyer on State Street
Why it made the list

Martin P. Bonventre, Esq. is a solo criminal defense practice at 41 State Street that opened in 2011, according to his published profile. His attorney directory listings include sex crimes and internet crimes among criminal defense areas, alongside DWI and personal injury, and court records show he has argued sex offender civil management appeals. His profile describes the practice as offering personal attention at an affordable price. Because he works alone, the person you meet is the person who appears in court.

Proof file
  • AttorneyMartin P. Bonventre; practice opened 2011 · Attorney profiles; NY attorney registration not checked this run
  • Office41 State St, Suite M100, Albany, NY 12207 · Google, Justia profile
  • Phone518-227-1776 · Google, Justia profile
  • Practice areas listedCriminal defense including sex crimes and internet crimes; DWI; personal injury · Justia and Cornell LII attorney profiles
  • Fee termsFree consultation listed; fees not published · Justia profile
  • Google rating4.9 from 59 reviews · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QHow many sex crime cases have you handled at trial, and in which courts?
QIs your fee flat or hourly, and what does it include if the case goes to trial?
QWho covers for you if you are in another trial on my court date?
From the reviews we read
+ Responsive and calming+ Clear about options+ Reasonable cost~ No sex crime reviews read

The Google reviews we read describe him as responsive, calming and clear about options, and several mention a reasonable cost for the result. The matters described include traffic and general criminal cases; we read none that describe a sex crime defense.

Fit and watch-outSuited to someone who wants a hands-on solo lawyer at a lower price downtown. The trade-off: sex crimes appear only in directory listings rather than a published practice page, and a solo practice has limited backup.

04

Six things to settle before you sign with a sex crimes defense lawyer

 

A written retainer agreement. Get the fee, what it covers and what happens at trial in writing. New York court rules require a written letter of engagement or retainer agreement when the fee is $3,000 or more.

 

Who handles the case. Name the attorney who will appear at every court date and the one who covers if they are unavailable.

 

The registration hearing. Ask whether the fee includes the risk-level hearing that follows a conviction or plea to a registerable offense.

 

Investigators and forensic review. Ask whether forensic computer review, investigators or a psychologist are included or billed separately.

 

No statements without counsel. Agree that the lawyer, not you, will speak to police or a detective, including in any pre-arrest call.

 

Related proceedings. If a school, employer, licensing board or the military may act on the same accusation, ask who handles that side.

05

Frequently asked questions

How long does sex offender registration last in New York?+
A Level 1 registrant is on the registry for 20 years. Level 2 and Level 3 registrants register for life, though a Level 2 registrant without a special designation may petition for relief after 30 years.
Should I talk to police if I am accused of a sex crime in Albany?+
Speak with a lawyer first. Anything you say to a detective can be used in court, and a lawyer can handle the conversation for you, including before any charge is filed.
Which court hears a sex crime case in Albany?+
Misdemeanors arising in the City of Albany usually stay in Albany City Court. Felony charges are presented to a grand jury and, after indictment, tried in Albany County Court at 16 Eagle Street.
What if I cannot afford a lawyer?+
Ask the court to assign one at your arraignment. In Albany County, eligible people are usually represented by the Public Defender’s Office at no cost.
Does O’Brien & Eggleston PLLC defend sex crime charges in Albany?+
Yes. O’Brien & Eggleston PLLC at 12 Sheridan Ave, Suite 3, lists sexual assault, statutory rape, child pornography and other sex offenses on its Albany sex crimes page and offers a free consultation, according to its website.
Can a sex crime accusation affect my professional license or school?+
Yes. A licensing board, college Title IX office or the military can act separately from the criminal case. Ask any firm whether it handles those proceedings too.

06

Method and sources

How we checked these firms+

This is a shortlist of five Capital Region firms that defend people accused of sex crimes, not a ranking. For each firm we read the page named in its entry for services, attorneys and fee terms, checked its Google Business Profile for address, phone and review count, and read the review text. We did not confirm attorney registrations on the New York court system’s search this run, and each entry says so.

Results, trial counts and years of experience are each firm’s own statements and are labelled that way. Registration periods come from the New York Division of Criminal Justice Services and the Correction Law. Three firms originally suggested for this page were left out because one represents accusers in civil suits and two practice in Ohio and in Rochester.

Sources+
  1. Firm websites: oe-legaldefense.com, albanycriminalattorney.com, tullylegal.com, oalaw.com; Justia and Cornell LII attorney profiles for Martin P. Bonventre (read November 2026)
  2. Google Business Profiles for each firm: address, phone, rating, review count and review text (checked November 2026)
  3. New York Division of Criminal Justice Services, sex offender risk levels and registration periods
  4. New York Correction Law 168-h and 168-o
  5. Albany County Public Defender, albanycounty.com
  6. FindLaw listing of sex crime lawyers serving Albany County

General information for people facing a sex crime accusation in New York, not legal advice. Registration rules and court procedures change; confirm them with a New York criminal defense lawyer.

Scroll to Top