Top 5 Hot Coffee Burn Lawyers for Pennsylvania Claims (2026)

Burn Claim Dossier · Pennsylvania · Updated November 15, 2026

Five injury firms a hot coffee burn victim might call, checked against bar records, Google reviews and their own fee terms.

Pennsylvania gives most injured people two years to sue and cuts off recovery when their own share of fault is greater than the defendants’. Both rules bite in a spill case, where the defense often points at the person holding the cup.

0 of 5
firms here publish a contingency percentage
2 years
to file suit, and no recovery if your fault outweighs theirs
$30
most a PBA referral consultation can cost

The Pagano Law Firm is listed first on this page. The order of the other four is not a ranking. Each fact below was checked against the source named beside it for this guide, last updated November 15, 2026.

01

The scorecard: 5 checks, 5 firms

✓ meets the check   ◐ partly or self-reported   ✗ does not, or not published

The Pagano Law Firm, LLCSpill and scald victims in Delaware County and the Main Line who want a firm that writes about coffee burns specifically
Office in SE Pennsylvania

✓Radnor

PA bar record checked

✓Active, no history

Burn or hot liquid page

✓Hot coffee page

Fee terms published

◐Free consult only

Google rating checked

✓4.6 / 20

Messa LawSevere burns that may turn on a defective cup, lid or brewer and need a large trial firm
Office in SE Pennsylvania

✓Center City

PA bar record checked

✓Active, no history

Burn or hot liquid page

◐Fires and burns

Fee terms published

◐Contingency, no %

Google rating checked

✓3.9 / 98

Pisanchyn Law FirmBurn victims in northeastern, central or western Pennsylvania who want a firm that answers around the clock
Office in SE Pennsylvania

✗Scranton, Harrisburg, Pgh

PA bar record checked

◐Active, 2009 censure

Burn or hot liquid page

◐Under catastrophic

Fee terms published

◐No fee unless win

Google rating checked

✓4.7 / 189

Tim Rayne (MacElree Harvey)Chester County residents with a smaller scald who want one lawyer’s straight read on whether they need a lawyer at all
Office in SE Pennsylvania

✓Kennett Sq, West Chester

PA bar record checked

✓Active, no history

Burn or hot liquid page

✗Not found

Fee terms published

◐No fee unless recovery

Google rating checked

✓5.0 / 17

Buckfire LawPennsylvania residents burned by a hot drink while in Michigan, where the claim belongs in Michigan
Office in SE Pennsylvania

✗Michigan only

PA bar record checked

✗Not PA licensed

Burn or hot liquid page

✗Not confirmed

Fee terms published

◐Written promise, no %

Google rating checked

✓4.7 / 974

02

Before you sign: what the numbers mean for a burn claim

1
0 of 5: firms here publish a contingency percentage
All five offer a free first consultation and describe some form of no recovery, no fee. None prints the percentage it takes. Messa Law says case costs can come out of the recovery, and Buckfire Law says it advances costs. Ask for the percentage, and whether it rises if the case is filed or tried, before you sign.
SOURCE · Firm websites, read November 2026
2
2 years: to file suit, and no recovery if your fault outweighs theirs
42 Pa.C.S. 5524 requires a personal injury suit within two years. Under 42 Pa.C.S. 7102, damages shrink by the injured person’s share of fault and stop entirely if that share is greater than the defendants’ combined. In a spill case the defense often argues the customer caused it, so the cup, the receipt and photos matter early.
SOURCE · 42 Pa.C.S. 5524 and 7102 (Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes)
3
$30: most a PBA referral consultation can cost
If none of these firms fits, the Pennsylvania Bar Association Lawyer Referral Service covers 45 of the 67 counties and caps the first half-hour consultation at $30. Philadelphia and several suburban counties run their own services instead; the Philadelphia Bar’s referral is free and its first consultation is $35.
SOURCE · Pennsylvania Bar Association LRS; Philadelphia Bar LRIS listing on PA 211

03

The 5 firm dossiers

01

The Pagano Law Firm, LLC

Spill and scald victims in Delaware County and the Main Line who want a firm that writes about coffee burns specifically
Why it made the list

The Pagano Law Firm is the one firm in this group with a page written only about hot coffee burn cases, and it works from Radnor, in Delaware County, for clients across southeastern Pennsylvania and nearby New Jersey. Its page sets out the four things a burn plaintiff has to prove (duty, breach, causation and damages) and names the three ways these cases usually start: coffee served too hot, a cup that fails, or a server who spills it. Managing partner Marlo Pagano-Kelleher was admitted in Pennsylvania in 1999. The firm also takes employment and business matters.

Proof file
  • Lead attorneyMarlo Pagano-Kelleher, managing partner · Firm listing, PA Disciplinary Board
  • Bar recordPA ID 84503, admitted 1999, active; no discipline history and no pending proceedings · PA Disciplinary Board, checked November 2026
  • Office201 King of Prussia Rd, Suite 650, Office 616, Radnor, PA 19087; weekdays 9 to 5 · Google Business Profile
  • Phone484-318-2561 · Firm hot coffee burn page
  • Area servedSoutheastern Pennsylvania and nearby New Jersey · Firm hot coffee burn page
  • Fee termsFree consultation stated; contingency percentage not published · Firm hot coffee burn page
  • Burn coveragePage on hot coffee burns: liability, the McDonald’s case, damages for scarring · Firm website
  • Google rating4.6 from 20 reviews · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QHow many hot liquid or scald cases have you handled, and did any involve a restaurant chain or drive-through?
QWho will hold my file day to day, Marlo Pagano-Kelleher or another attorney?
QIf my burn happened in New Jersey, who on your team handles it there?
From the reviews we read
+ Honest about likely outcome+ Kept clients informed~ Some reviews from business work~ Slow reply on a declined matter

Reviewers describe Marlo Pagano-Kelleher as straightforward about what a case is likely to be worth and say she kept them informed through to a settlement. Some reviews come from contract and small business work rather than injury claims. One reviewer says the firm was slow to answer before declining a civil case, which is worth a direct question at intake.

Fit and watch-outThe closest match in this group to the exact injury, with a local Radnor office and a clean bar record for its managing partner. The trade-off: a smaller review base (20 on Google) and a practice split across injury, employment and business work, so ask how much of the docket is burn and premises cases.
02

Messa Law

Severe burns that may turn on a defective cup, lid or brewer and need a large trial firm
Why it made the list

Messa Law lists fires, burns and explosions as its own practice area and runs it from 123 S 22nd St in Center City Philadelphia, with offices it lists in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York and Florida. By its own figures it is the largest practice in this group: it states more than $2 billion recovered, and its homepage lists a $35.5 million recovery for a fatal fire caused by a defective heater. Founder Joseph L. Messa Jr. was admitted in 1988. The firm runs a Spanish-language site, and it handles products liability, the route when the cup or lid failed rather than the server.

Proof file
  • Lead attorneyJoseph L. Messa Jr., founder · Firm website
  • Bar recordPA ID 53645, admitted 1988, active; no discipline history and no pending proceedings · PA Disciplinary Board, checked November 2026
  • Office123 S 22nd St, Philadelphia, PA 19103; other offices listed in NJ, NY and FL · Google Business Profile, firm footer
  • Phone215-515-4213 · Firm site, Google
  • Fee termsContingency; case costs may be deducted from the recovery; percentage not published · Firm FAQ
  • Burn coverageFires, Burns and Explosions practice page; products liability practice · Firm website
  • Track recordStates over $2 billion recovered · Firm’s own figure
  • Google rating3.9 from 98 reviews · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QWould a coffee burn case stay with a partner here, or go to a newer associate?
QIf the lid or cup failed, would you bring a product claim alongside the negligence claim?
QHow often will I hear from my attorney directly, and by what channel?
From the reviews we read
+ Candid about complex cases+ Attorneys credited by name~ Alleged long gap in contact~ 3.9 average, lowest here

Reviewers credit individual attorneys by name and describe candor about cases that turned out more complex than expected, including a fatal crash case handled over several years. One detailed review alleges more than two years without direct contact from the assigned attorney. The 3.9 average across 98 reviews is the lowest score in this group.

Fit and watch-outThe deepest bench in this list for a severe burn with skin grafts or a possible product defect. The trade-off: a 3.9 Google average with at least one serious communication complaint, and a docket built around very large cases, so a smaller scald claim may get less attention.
03

Pisanchyn Law Firm

Burn victims in northeastern, central or western Pennsylvania who want a firm that answers around the clock
Why it made the list

Pisanchyn Law Firm handles burns as part of its catastrophic injury practice from offices in Scranton, Harrisburg and Pittsburgh, plus Williamsport, and says it will meet clients wherever it accepts a case. Burns do not have a page of their own. By its own statement it answers phones 24 hours a day, and it offers a text line. Founder Michael Pisanchyn Jr. was admitted in 2001; the Disciplinary Board record shows a public censure on consent in 2009 and no pending proceedings. A large Social Security disability practice runs alongside the injury work.

Proof file
  • Lead attorneyMichael Pisanchyn Jr., founder · Firm website
  • Bar recordPA ID 87542, admitted 2001, active; public censure on consent, 2009 (118 DB 2007); no pending proceedings · PA Disciplinary Board, checked November 2026
  • OfficesScranton (524 Biden St), Harrisburg (3609 N Front St), Pittsburgh (241 Fourth Ave), Williamsport · Firm website, Google
  • Phone570-344-1234; 1-800-444-5309 · Firm website, Google
  • Fee termsNo fee unless the firm wins; percentage not published · Firm website
  • Burn coverageBurns listed under catastrophic injury; no burn-specific page · Firm website
  • Track recordStates over $100 million settled and 1,000+ cases won · Firm’s own figure
  • Google rating4.7 from 189 reviews (Scranton profile) · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QHow many burn or scald cases has the firm taken in the last few years?
QIf I live near Philadelphia, which office and which attorney would handle my case?
QWhat does the 2009 censure involve, and what changed afterward?
From the reviews we read
+ A real person answers+ Clear explanations+ Staff keep in touch~ Many reviews from SSDI cases

Reviewers say a real person answers the phone, praise named attorneys for patience and plain explanations, and describe staff who stayed in touch. Many of the reviews we read come from Social Security disability and car crash clients, so they speak to service style more than to burn claims.

Fit and watch-outA reachable statewide firm with the second-largest review base here and offices outside the Philadelphia area. The trade-off: no burn-specific page, no office in southeastern Pennsylvania, and a public discipline record on its founder that a client should ask about directly.
04

Tim Rayne (MacElree Harvey)

Chester County residents with a smaller scald who want one lawyer’s straight read on whether they need a lawyer at all
Why it made the list

Tim Rayne is a single named lawyer inside MacElree Harvey, a full-service firm, and practices Chester County personal injury law from Kennett Square and West Chester. He was admitted in 1995 and states more than 30 years with injured clients. Two points set him apart. He says some callers do not need to hire a lawyer and he will tell them so, which suits a minor scald with a small medical bill. And his practice list includes dangerous products, the route for a cup or lid failure. He has no page on burns, so ask how many hot liquid cases he has handled.

Proof file
  • Lead attorneyTimothy F. Rayne, partner at MacElree Harvey, Ltd. · Firm website
  • Bar recordPA ID 75589, admitted 1995, active; no discipline history and no pending proceedings · PA Disciplinary Board, checked November 2026
  • Offices209 E State St, Kennett Square, PA 19348; 17 W Miner St, West Chester, PA 19382 · Firm website, Google
  • Phone610-840-0124 · Firm website, Google
  • Fee termsFree consultation; no attorney’s fee unless there is a recovery; percentage not published · Firm website
  • Burn coverageNo burn page; dangerous products and slip and fall pages · Firm website
  • Free resourceFree downloadable book on insurance and injury claims · Firm website
  • Google rating5.0 from 17 reviews · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QHave you handled a hot coffee or hot liquid burn, and how did it resolve?
QIf you think I can handle the claim myself, what would you tell me to do first?
QWhich parts of my case would you handle personally, and which would go to others at MacElree Harvey?
From the reviews we read
+ Personal attention from Rayne+ Explains each step+ Premises and dog bite settlements~ 17 reviews, a small base

Reviewers describe Rayne himself answering questions and explaining each step, with settlements in premises, dog bite and pedestrian cases. One older client says a black ice fall case settled in about 14 months. All 17 reviews we could see were positive, a small base.

Fit and watch-outA good fit for a Chester County client who wants to deal with one experienced lawyer and an honest read on whether a lawyer is needed. The trade-off: no burn page, a 17-review base, and a practice centered on Chester County rather than the wider Philadelphia area.
05

Buckfire Law

Pennsylvania residents burned by a hot drink while in Michigan, where the claim belongs in Michigan
Why it made the list

Buckfire Law is the only firm here with no Pennsylvania office, and its own disclaimer says its principal is licensed only in Michigan and Ohio. It is a Michigan personal injury firm based in Southfield with offices in Detroit, Ann Arbor, Shelby Township and Flint. It belongs on this list for one reader: someone from Pennsylvania burned by coffee during a trip to Michigan, where Michigan law and its three-year filing period would generally apply. It puts its No-Fee Promise in writing, advances case costs, and its main Google profile carries 974 reviews, the largest base in this group.

Proof file
  • Lead attorneyLawrence J. Buckfire, named as responsible for the firm’s advertising · Firm website disclaimer
  • LicenceLicensed only in Michigan and Ohio by the firm’s own statement; not checked on the State Bar of Michigan · Firm website disclaimer
  • OfficesSouthfield (main), Detroit, Ann Arbor, Shelby Township, Flint, all in Michigan · Firm website, Google
  • Phone248-595-7544 (Southfield); 800-606-1717 · Google, firm website
  • Fee termsNo-Fee Promise in writing; firm advances case costs; percentage not published · Firm fees page
  • Filing periodThree years for most Michigan personal injury suits · MCL 600.5805(2)
  • Google rating4.7 from 974 reviews (Southfield profile) · Google, checked November 2026
Your first-call script
QMy burn happened in Michigan but I live in Pennsylvania. Can you handle it without me travelling for every step?
QWhich attorney, not case manager, would own my file?
QWhat does your written No-Fee Promise say about costs if there is no recovery?
From the reviews we read
+ Responsive case managers+ Regular check-ins+ Car crash settlements~ Few or no burn cases in reviews

Reviewers name case managers as often as attorneys and describe fast replies and regular check-ins through car crash settlements. One five-star review comes from a scholarship recipient rather than a client, so the count overstates client feedback slightly. Almost none of the reviews we read involve burns.

Fit and watch-outThe right call only when the burn happened in Michigan; for a Pennsylvania injury it cannot take the case itself. The trade-off: a very large review base and written fee promise, but no Pennsylvania licence and no burn-specific practice we could confirm on its site.

04

Six things to settle before you sign a fee agreement

 

The fee in writing. Pennsylvania’s Rule of Professional Conduct 1.5(c) requires a contingent fee agreement to be in writing. Read the percentage, and whether it changes if a suit is filed or the case goes to trial.

 

Costs if there is no recovery. Ask who pays filing fees, medical records and witness costs if the case is lost, and whether costs come out before or after the fee is calculated.

 

Who handles the case. Get the name of the attorney who will own your file and how often you will hear from that person directly.

 

Keep the evidence. Save the cup, lid, sleeve and receipt, photograph the burn as it heals, and note the store, time and any staff names. These answer the fault question under 42 Pa.C.S. 7102.

 

Mark the two-year date. Write down the date two years from the burn. Waiting for a store’s insurer to make an offer does not stop that clock.

 

Where it happened. A burn in New Jersey or Michigan is usually handled under that state’s rules and by a lawyer licensed there. Tell each firm the location on the first call.

05

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to file a hot coffee burn lawsuit in Pennsylvania?+
Most personal injury suits in Pennsylvania must be filed within two years under 42 Pa.C.S. 5524. Some exceptions apply, for example for injured children, so confirm the date with a lawyer early.
Can I still recover if I spilled the coffee myself?+
Possibly. Under 42 Pa.C.S. 7102, your damages are reduced by your share of fault, and you recover nothing only if your share is greater than that of the defendants combined. A loose lid or a drink served too hot can shift that balance.
Who can be responsible for a coffee burn?+
The Pagano Law Firm’s burn page names three common sources: coffee served at too high a temperature, a cup that cannot hold the liquid, and a server who spills it. A restaurant is generally responsible for its employees’ negligence while they are working; a failed cup or lid can also raise a product claim.
What does a hot coffee burn lawyer cost?+
All five firms here offer a free consultation and work on some form of no recovery, no fee. None publishes its percentage. If you need a referral instead, the Pennsylvania Bar Association service caps the first half-hour consultation at $30.
Should I check a lawyer’s discipline record?+
Yes. The Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania lists each lawyer’s status, admission date and any public discipline. Four of the five lead attorneys here are Pennsylvania-licensed; one has a 2009 public censure on record.
What if I was burned outside Pennsylvania?+
The claim is usually brought where the injury happened. Buckfire Law, listed here, handles Michigan injury cases, where most suits must be filed within three years under MCL 600.5805(2).

06

Method and sources

How we checked these firms+

This is a shortlist of five law firms a person burned by hot coffee or another hot drink might contact, not a ranking. For each firm we read the page supplied to us and related pages for office, fee terms and burn coverage, checked the lead attorney on the Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania attorney search, and read Google Business Profile ratings and review text.

Results, recovery totals and awards are each firm’s own statements and are labelled that way. Where we could not confirm something, the entry says so. The Pennsylvania deadline and fault rules come from the statute text, not from a firm’s blog.

Sources+
  1. Firm websites: paganolawyers.com, messalaw.com, pisanchynlawfirm.com, timraynelaw.com, buckfirelaw.com (read November 2026)
  2. Google Business Profiles for each firm: address, phone, rating, review count and review text (checked November 2026)
  3. Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, attorney search: IDs 84503, 53645, 87542, 75589
  4. 42 Pa.C.S. 5524 (two-year limitation) and 42 Pa.C.S. 7102 (comparative negligence)
  5. Pennsylvania Rule of Professional Conduct 1.5(c) (contingent fee agreements in writing)
  6. Pennsylvania Bar Association Lawyer Referral Service; Philadelphia Bar Association LRIS listing on PA 211
  7. Michigan Compiled Laws 600.5805(2)

General information for people choosing a lawyer, not legal advice. Check the current statute text or ask a lawyer licensed in your state before relying on it.

“`html

“`

Scroll to Top